For a faulty iPhone 5s «M.Video” pay 140,000 rubles




Timiryazevskiy Moscow district court partially granted the women customers, which went to a faulty iPhone. According to the court retailer has to pay 140,600 rubles, although he could lose substantially less if agreed to the proposal of the plaintiff’s lawyer in the second round of “talks” about the settlement agreement.


According to Pravo , April 20, the Oksana Guseva bought for 39,900 rubles. Smartphone iPhone 5s 64 GB in gold performance in the store network “M. Video” in Saransk, and after a couple of months longer smartphone turned on and, according to women customers, “DO NOT START” and “did not respond to the charger.” Later, July 22, in Moscow, she came to the office and wrote a statement to the retailer to return the money paid for the gadget, and the company she refused, citing the fact that “there was a lack of product after 15 days.”

Then, on August 26, enlisting the conclusion of technical expertise fault iPhone, Gusev filed a lawsuit against “M. Video” in the Timiryazevskiy District Court in Moscow. She asked recover from the defendant the cost of a smartphone, 58 000 rubles. forfeit 10 000 rubles. for non-pecuniary damage and 70 000 rubles. reimbursement for services representative in court, 900 rubles. for examination, and the penalty for failure to comply with the consumer on a voluntary basis (49 000 rub.).

This week, the case was heard by Judge Alena Kashin. She reminded about the approaching New Year and asked representatives of the parties, if they wanted to resolve the dispute peacefully.

“I have offered them for 100 000 rubles. They refused … “- threw up his hands the plaintiff’s attorney Andrew Pinnacles.

“In less disagree?” – Asked the plaintiff’s attorney judge.

“They are so rude behaved … No!” – Was categorical Pinnacles and then Fedorov offered this option: in addition to the reimbursement of iPhone, give the plaintiff a new smartphone. According to him, in which case it would have received 60,000 rubles. But Goltsov was ready to throw off the claim by only 10 000 rubles., And negotiate peace failed.

After that Goltsov supported the statement requirements, and a lawyer “M. Video” presented to the court paper signed by the plaintiff May 5, 2014 in a shop in Saransk. It means she refuses to give the phone for troubleshooting. “Why have refused to give the phone, it is not clear – commented Fedorov. – To recognize the claim in part, ready to reimburse only the cost of the phone. Suppose the merchandise is defective, but where the seller knows about it? The plaintiff has violated our rights, too. ”

Kashin again invited to resolve the matter peacefully, and started the third round of “negotiations”. Loaches said he was willing to be satisfied with 80 000 rubles., But Fedorov such a proposal was not ready to accept. As a result, “M. Video” will have to pay 140,000 rubles.

See also:

Return with interest: how to get three prices for low-quality gadget?

Join us at Twitter , VKontakte , Facebook , Google+ or via RSS , to keep abreast of the latest news from the world of Apple, Microsoft and Google.

Tags: , , , ,

In: Technology & Gadgets Asked By: [18454 Red Star Level]

Answer this Question

You must be Logged In to post an Answer.

Not a member yet? Sign Up Now »

Star Points Scale

Earn points for Asking and Answering Questions!

Grey Sta Levelr [1 - 25 Grey Star Level]
Green Star Level [26 - 50 Green Star Level]
Blue Star Level [51 - 500 Blue Star Level]
Orange Star Level [501 - 5000 Orange Star Level]
Red Star Level [5001 - 25000 Red Star Level]
Black Star Level [25001+ Black Star Level]